Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Business gets behind Allegra Spender’s 40% CGT plan as Labor puts their trusts in Greens votes

Must Read

The Business Council of Australia (BCA) and the Council of Small Business Organisations Australia (COSBOA) have joined the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ACCI) and the Australian Industry Group in supporting Spender.

The independent MP, cofounder of Australia’s newest political party, Community Strong Australia, said hundreds of entrepreneurs and businesspeople have signed her open letter to PM Anthony Albanese and treasurer Jim Chalmers on changing the government’s current CGT carve-out.

Spender’s proposal treats all risk-taking businesses equally, a flat 40% CGT discount, meaning a effective maximum capital tax rate of 28%.

“It is a no brainer. It doesn’t change the government’s tax settings on housing and raises the same revenue as the government’s own proposal,” according to the PBO,” Spender said.

“In a productivity crisis, we can’t afford to be putting the handbrake on business formation and growth.”

Under the budget changes, passed in June, with amendments now before the Senate, only certain “innovative businesses”, prepared to jump through bureaucratic hoops annually in order to qualify, would fall outside the broader changes to CGT.

The 50% discount mostly falls away in favour of inflation indexation for gains accruing from 1 July, 2027. The problem is that while inflation can add substantially to the cost base of a $1 million property, it has minimal impact of building a business from nothing and shares a founder took up for $1, after a decade of work has made them worth 50 or 100x.

The current proposal treats active and passive investments equally, ignoring risk and effort for reward.

Labor’s proposed Innovative Business CGT Concession (IBCC) preserves the 50% discount for founders, employees and early investors who hold qualifying equity for at least three years. But it’s a complex, compliance-driven process, retrofitted following backlash to the concerns of the startup and broader business sectors.

Chalmers eased the rules in October, but companies still have to show that innovation accounts for more than half of at least two of three measures covering assets, workers and income.

The Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 4) Bill 2026 also includes changes to the R&D Tax Incentive and expanded venture capital incentives. That means it’s a 3-in-1, all-or-nothing bill for the government.

The legislation passed the lower house last month, but now needs cross-bench support in the Senate to become law.

Spender’s point is that the government’s proposed fix for business is “too narrow and too complex to be effective”.

“The Government say they are listening to business. Let’s see that in action. The major business groups and hundreds of individual entrepreneurs are urging the Prime Minister and the Treasurer to take this opportunity, work with us, and get this reform right before the damage is done.”

With just a fortnight of sittings left in the parliamentary year, the government is time-pressed to get its agenda through before Christmas as organised resistance to the changes grows.

Last week, Wilson Asset Management founder Geoff Wilson launched Get Ahead Australia, a campaign opposing the tax changes, saying he plans to maintain the rage for 4.5 years – when the 2031 federal election is due – but he hopes it might take just 18 months, a nod to ousting the Albanese government at the 2028 poll.

Get Ahead was launched in Sydney last week with comedian Dave Hughes among the outspoken critics of the government appearing on stage.

Meanwhile, the government faces spot fires from a range of tax changes in the wake of the May budget. COSBOA and ACCI, have also written to every senator urging them to reject Labor’s proposed minimum tax on discretionary trusts. Chalmers wants those changes through the Senate before Christmas, but with the Coalition opposed, he needs the Greens, who want to make public the names of trust beneficiaries.

A key issue with Labor’s CGT changes is that they bring back the complexity in calculating capital gains identified in the 1999 Ralph review of business taxation, which led to the Howard government introducing the current CGT rules.

In looking to address the nation’s predilection for property investment, and unaffordable housing, treasurer Jim Chalmers threw the business baby out with the CGT bathwater.

As NAB CEO Andrew Irvine told the House Economics Committee last week, when asked about tax settings for existing housing versus business investment, he “could live with” the changes to negative gearing and to CGT on property. But risk assets should be taxed at lower levels than passive or property, he argued, because someone who starts and builds a successful business should be taxed less than property investors “because they’ve taken risk.”

The Spender proposal scraps the government’s tests and limits based on a company age and turnover to qualify for the IBCC scheme. Her discount would cover active business assets, including shares and employee options.

That means an employee weighing up lower pay at a startup, in favour of share options or an angel investor could work out how much of a future gain would be taxable without having to assess the additional risk of whether the startup will still qualify years later.

On a $100,000 gain after the change, a founder who qualifies for Labor’s concession would include $50,000 in taxable income. Under Spender’s plan, that rises to $60,000, but a much wider group of business owners and investors could count on the discount.

The Parliamentary Budget Office estimates Spender’s plan would raise $590 million more through 2029–30 than the government’s model with the IBCC in place.

ACCI’s Andrew McKellar called Labor’s carve-out an “obstacle course” saying the independent MP’s proposal deserves serious consideration.

“Allegra Spender’s proposal is a practical place to start. It’s simpler than the obstacle course that is the proposed start-up ‘carve-out’, and it backs businesses that take risks,” he said.

COSBOA’s Skye Cappuccio sees greater certainty for growing businesses, while Ai Group’s Innes Willox said the change would help Australia compete for investment.

“What this proposal may offer is a simpler, fairer approach for medium-sized businesses,” Cappuccio said.

“We need tax settings that encourage businesses to invest, grow and create jobs, without adding unnecessary complexity.”

BCA chief executive Bran Black backs Spender’s compromise, although the council still prefers the Coalition’s promise of full repeal.

As SmartCompany’s David Adams reported, the Labor-chaired Senate Economics Legislation Committee backed a 30% minimum tax on discretionary trusts from 1 July 2028. It argued the change would make the system fairer for families who earn wages and receive no trust distributions.

Coalition senators wanted the trust measures withdrawn, examined in a longer inquiry or delayed until mid-2029.

Greens senator Nick McKim broadly supports the minimum tax. He wants the government to use Australian Taxation Office and Australian Bureau of Statistics data to publish a beneficial ownership register covering trusts. That could identify family members receiving distributions from a business.

A deal on disclosure would still leave Chalmers to decide whether to take up Spender’s 40% alternative in the separate bill covering startup investment.

Another open letter to senators opposing the discretionary trusts changes was signed by COSBOA, ACCI signed by the Housing Industry Association, Master Builders Australia and the Property Council of Australia.

They argue each option carries a cost for family businesses. Trustees could pay the minimum tax, restructure the business or make a binding election fixing each beneficiary’s share.

Spender has also raised this issue in Parliament, and the additional costs imposed as people rearrange their financial affiairs pointing out that the states had yet to guarantee they’d waive stamp duty for businesses moving assets out of a trust.

This week, Greens treasury spokesperson Nick McKim said he’d spoken to Spender about the 40% CGT discount and would welcome a Senate inquiry examining it over summer. M

Meawnhile treasurer Jim Chalmers said on Tuesday he’ ha’d written to Spender outlining Treasury’s concerns that her proposal could add complexity, create opportunities for tax avoidance and leave some startup founders paying more tax.

If you’re looking for an expert on complexity, Chalmers is your go to for advice. And irony died the moment the treasurer said he was concerned about a business paying more tax.

You can sign Allegra Spender’s open letter to the PM and treasurer here.

 

- Advertisement -spot_img
- Advertisement -spot_img
Latest News

News Wrap: U.S. no longer considered a measles-free nation

In our news wrap Tuesday, international health officials say the United States is no longer considered a measles-free nation,...
- Advertisement -spot_img

More Articles Like This

- Advertisement -spot_img